Nobody is impressed by a PhD anymore. Here's how to deal with it.

Leaving a PhD program—or deciding to pivot after years in academia—can feel like failure. But as Dr. Gertrude Nonterah and Dr. David Mendes discussed on The Bold PhD Podcast, it’s not failure at all. It’s a realignment—a chance to reimagine who you are and what you want your life to look like beyond the degree.

CLICK THE PLAY BUTTON TO WATCH THE VIDEO:

CLICK TO LISTEN TO THE AUDIO:

*Pre-order my new book on finding a fulfilling career outside academia: https://amzn.to/4qf2riE

* Chapter 1 of my new book: Navigating The P.I.V.O.T. on YouTube

* Chapter 1 of my new book: Navigating The P.I.V.O.T. on Apple Podcasts.

When Quitting Feels Like Losing Yourself

Many people leave a PhD not because they aren’t capable, but because life happens—health challenges, family responsibilities, or the realization that academia no longer aligns with their values. As Dr. Nonterah shared, grief and anger are natural parts of that process. You’ve built an identity around being “the scholar,” and walking away can feel like losing yourself.

Staying stuck in resentment—even years later—robs you of mental space for what’s next.

“You don’t free up the space for all the possibilities of who you could become,” Dr. Nonterah noted.

Instead, allow yourself to process the emotions, but don’t let them calcify into your identity. You are not your unfinished PhD. You are someone who made a conscious, courageous choice to protect your wellbeing and pursue alignment.

Redefining Success on Your Terms

North American culture often equates leaving with failure. But “failing forward”—recognizing when a path no longer fits and taking deliberate steps in a new direction—is a mark of wisdom, not weakness.

He encourages PhDs to reclaim their agency: “You have values. You have needs. You’re entitled to reorient and say, ‘I tried this, I learned from it, and now I’m moving on.’”

If your program allows it, consider mastering out—completing a master’s degree en route to leaving the PhD. It gives closure to your efforts and keeps the door open to many professional paths.

Building Your “Life Jacket”

One of the most powerful insights from this conversation was the idea of having a “life jacket”—a network beyond academia that can keep you afloat when things get uncertain.

Too many graduate students develop tunnel vision, surrounding themselves only with labmates or fellow scholars.

Dr. Mendes suggests intentionally nurturing relationships with people outside your department—old classmates, LinkedIn connections, or professionals in your field of interest. These relationships can provide honest insight, emotional support, and even job leads.

When you’re at a crossroads, you need people who aren’t invested in your academic success but in your wellbeing.

Why Networking Beats Online Job Applications

Both Dr. Nonterah and Dr. Mendes agreed: the most successful transitions happen through people, not job boards.

“Getting your diploma and holding it over your head like in The Lion King and saying, ‘Here I am—hire me,’ doesn’t work,” Dr. Mendes said.

Around 70–80% of jobs are never posted online. They’re filled through conversations, referrals, and relationships—what’s called the hidden job market. That’s why building your network before you leave academia is crucial.

Overcoming the “Overqualified” Label

Many PhDs struggle with feeling “overqualified” for roles outside academia. The key, Dr. Nonterah advises, is to stop leading with the degree and start leading with your skills.

Translate your experience into language that resonates with employers: project management, research analysis, writing, teaching, collaboration, data storytelling. These are universal skills.

In industry, experience often trumps credentials.

As Dr. Nonterah put it, “I’ve had managers without PhDs who led teams because they had the skills and experience to do so.”

Life After Academia Is Still Life

Walking away from academia isn’t an ending—it’s an opening. There are countless examples of people who left PhD programs and built fulfilling, impactful careers—from advocacy to science communication.

If you’re navigating this transition, surround yourself with community. Build your life jacket. And give yourself permission to let go of what no longer serves you—so you can build a career and a life that do.